Still Life (2005)
2006 New Blood Dagger
2006 Arthur Ellis Award for Best First Novel
2007 Anthony Award for Best First Novel
2007 Barry Award for Best First Novel
2007 Dilys Award
Finalist 2010 Barry Award for Best Novel of the Decade

Dead Cold (2006)
APA: A Fatal Grace (2007)
2007 Agatha Award for Best Novel

The Cruelest Month (2007)
2008 Agatha Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2009 Anthony Award for Best Mystery
Finalist 2009 Barry Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2008 Arthur Ellis Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2009 Macavity Award for Best Novel

The Murder Stone (2008)
APA: A Rule Against Murder (2009) [review]
Finalist 2009 Arthur Ellis Award for Best Novel

The Brutal Telling (2009) [review]
2009 Agatha Award for Best Novel
2010 Anthony Award for Best Mystery
Finalist 2010 Dilys Award
Finalist 2010 Macavity Award for Best Novel

Bury Your Dead (2010) [review]
2010 Agatha Award for Best Novel
2011 Dilys Award
2011 Anthony Award for Best Mystery
2011 Arthur Ellis Award for Best Novel
2010 Macavity Award for Best Novel
2011 Nero Award
Finalist 2011 Barry Award for Best Novel

A Trick of the Light (2011) [review]
2012 Anthony Award for Best Mystery
Finalist 2011 Agatha Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2012 Dilys Award
Finalist 2012 Arthur Ellis Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2012 Macavity Award for Best Mystery

The Beautiful Mystery (2012) [review]
2012 Agatha Award for Best Novel
2013 Anthony Award for Best Mystery
2013 Macavity Award for Best Mystery

How the Light Gets In (2013) [review]
2014 Left Coast Crime Calamari Award
Finalist 2013 Agatha Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2014 Gold Dagger Award
Finalist 2014 Edgar Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2014 Macavity Award for Best Mystery

The Long Way Home (2014)
Finalist 2014 Agatha Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2015 Anthony Award for Best Mystery
Finalist 2015 Macavity Award for Best Mystery

The Nature of the Beast (2015)
Finalist 2015 Agatha Award for Best Contemporary Novel
Finalist 2016 Anthony Award for Best Mystery
Finalist 2016 Anthony Award for Best Audiobook
2016 Lefty Award for Best World Mystery

A Great Reckoning (2016)
2016 Agatha Award for Best Contemporary Novel
2017 Anthony Award for Best Mystery
2017 Barry Award for Best Novel
2017 Lefty Award for Best Mystery
2017 Macavity Award for Best Mystery

Glass Houses (2017)
2017 Agatha Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2018 Anthony Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2018 Anthony Award for Best Series Novel
Finalist 2018 Lefty Award for Best Mystery
Finalist 2018 Macavity Award for Best Mystery

Kingdom of the Blind (2018)
Finalist 2018 Agatha Award for Best Contemporary Novel
Finalist 2019 Arthur Ellis Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2019 Lefty Award for Best Mystery

A Better Man (2019)
Finalist 2019 Agatha Award for Best Contemporary Novel

All the Devils Are Here (2020)
2020 Agatha Award for Best Contemporary Novel
Finalist 2021 Barry Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2021 Lefty Award for Best Mystery
Finalist 2021 Macavity Award for Best Mystery

The Madness of Crowds (2021)
Finalist 2021 Agatha Award for Best Contemporary Novel

A World of Curiosities (2022)
2022 Agatha Award for Best Contemporary Novel
2023 Macavity Award for Best Mystery
Finalist 2023 Lefty Award for Best Mystery
Finalist 2023 Anthony Award for Best Hardcover

The Grey Wolf (2024)
Finalist 2025 Crime Writers of Canada Award for Best Novel
Finalist 2025 Anthony Award for Best Mystery